It’s hands like this that led me to stop limping into pots with small pairs. 🙂
As played though….After the villain’s flop bet, I would have put in a raise, probably to $100. I wouldn’t want to give the players behind me a good price to chase any draws. A bit of a moot point as they all folded anyway, but wanted to share my thought process. It’s doubtful you would have seen the straddler fold, and he wasn’t going anywhere on the turn. He got lucky and hit his “8 percenter” on the river.
Hopefully your next buy in went much better.